Ferrari Mailing List: Re: NFC, Looking for some Gun advice.

[Dave Handa (dave]

Quote below from Dr. Steve:

"For most folks, as a practical matter, virtually any high quality, smaller

dimension pistol will do, even a .32acp Walther PPK (no derogation of that
gun intended, simply mentioned as an example of a small calibre pistol)"

>From a "practical matter" meaning if you never need it.  We all know that
any firearm can be lethal, but we also know that small caliber handguns can
be very ineffective, particularly against a determined opponent.  Also, many
smaller dimension pistols can be more of a challenge to hold and shoot
accurately, and just as importantly, difficult to manipulate the slide in
the event of a stoppage.  

Example: I purchased a Kahr Arms, PM9 a very small, thin, 9mm pistol. It has
terrific inherent accuracy, but it's practical accuracy (at least for my
abilities) is less so, because of its tiny dimensions.  It is just very hard
to get a good firing grip on.

There are three distinct sizes of handguns out there.  Full size (or duty)
type handguns, compacts and the sub compact (which the 32acp typically falls
in). We have found in our classes, that students (private citizen or LE) can
shoot, manipulate and keep their gun running, when the gun is either of the
full size or compact size.  The sub compacts just have too small of
controls, and too small slides to be manipulated effectively.

If one feels the need to carry a handgun for defense, then it should be of
the largest caliber they can carry and use effectively.  Generally, the
minimum recommendation is a .380 auto or 38 special in revolver.  Now I
certainly agree that most do not need a 44 magnum revolver or a 45 win mag
semi-auto either, but recommending a 32 auto is contraindicated as well for
a general recommendation.  Sure, having any handgun is better than none, but
I would recommend that if one has reason enough to carry, to carry a more
effective caliber.